Will Competition in Rugby League Lead To League Tables?

Controversy is raging about whether the introduction of National Rugby League Standards will inevitably lead to the creation of league tables.

The Standards include a points system, where the scorer of a try earns four points for his team, while a penalty kick or conversion earns two points. A drop goal will be worth one point.

And the team that has the most points at the end of a game will be awarded a win.

A number of NRL clubs are opposed to the standards. The coach of the New Zealand Warriors, Ivan Cleary, said the standards would penalise poorly performing clubs and lead to newspapers and other media organisations creating league tables.

“Mate, this game should not be about who’s doing better or which club has better results,” said Cleary.

Others spoken to support the standards.

The coach of the Gold Coast Titans, John Cartwright, said “if we end up with league tables, then that’s fine with me. Fans have a right to know how their clubs are performing. It’s all about choice. If a club isn’t doing well or doesn’t meet the needs of a particular fan, that fan should be able to move to another club.

“League tables promote competition.”

But Cleary has attacked Cartwright’s comments.

“Competition? Give me a break. They have been trotting out the same tired old line for years. Isn’t playing rugby league at the very highest level meant to be about more than just results?

“Why can’t my players just be left alone? Why is there always such pressure on me to get results? It’s morale sapping. Excuse me, I need a lie down.”